Short answer: Look for seven things: a menu your managers will actually use, live rating on every eligible product, eContracting to your providers, deal data pulled from your DMS, automatic records of selections and declines, the same menu across every store, and real help during rollout. Then watch a real deal run start to finish in the demo.
Most F&I menu tools look alike in a sales deck. The differences show up on a busy Saturday. Use this checklist to compare options on the things that matter at the desk.
1. The menu itself
Can a manager build a clean presentation in a minute or two? Are packages easy to set up and change? Can the customer follow it without help? If your managers won’t use it on a rushed deal, nothing else on this list matters. New to the idea? Start with what a digital F&I menu is.
2. Live rating
Every product on the menu should show a real rate for that vehicle and deal, not a placeholder. Ask which of your current providers rate inside the tool and what happens with a provider that doesn’t. More on how eRating works.
3. eContracting to providers
After the customer chooses, how do product contracts reach the providers? Look for one submission for the whole deal instead of logging into several portals. Ask how rejected contracts are flagged and fixed. Here’s how eRating and eContracting fit together.
4. Deal data from your DMS
Re-keying the buyer and vehicle is slow and causes errors. Ask whether the tool pulls deal data from your DMS and which fields come over.
5. Records of selections and declines
The menu should record what each customer selected and declined, and you should be able to pull that record later without digging. Ask to see a saved deal.
6. Consistency across stores
For groups, every rooftop should run the same menu and products, with reporting by store and manager. See why a connected menu matters across locations.
7. Rollout, training and support
Ask how long setup takes, who trains your managers and who answers the phone when a deal is stuck.
The checklist
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Will managers use it on a rushed deal? | Adoption drives everything else |
| Are rates live for your providers? | Accurate numbers on the menu |
| Is there one submission for all product contracts? | Fewer portals, fewer errors |
| Does deal data come from your DMS? | No re-keying |
| Are selections and declines recorded? | A clean record for every deal |
| Is the menu the same at every store? | Consistent offers and reporting |
| Who handles setup and support? | A smooth rollout |
Ask to see a real deal go from rating to submitted contract during the demo. It tells you more than any feature list.
Where AmpliFI fits
AmpliFI covers each item on this list: one menu across every deal and store, live rating, one-click eContracting to providers, deal data from the dealer’s DMS and automatic decline records. Dealerships usually get AmpliFI through their F&I agent.
Agents and TPAs: Become a Preferred Partner
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I look for in F&I menu software?
A menu managers will use, live rating, eContracting, DMS data, decline records, multi-store consistency and rollout support.
How do I compare two menu tools?
Run the same sample deal in each demo, from rating to submitted contracts, and time it.
Should my F&I agent be involved?
Yes. Your agent knows your products and providers and can help set up the menu so it matches your product strategy.
